Review and Swatches: Essence I Love Style liquid liner vs. Eveline Liquid Precision 2000 procent eyeliner

Today I'll show you 2 black liners, I'm using at the moment. I have Essence I Love Style liner for more than a year now and I wasn't planning to review it, but then I bought Eveline Liquid precision 2000 procent liner in Black and I though, I should compare them. I'm using both for some time now and I think I can write some conclusions about them.

In Slovenia you can get Eveline products in Nama. They have 2 eyeliners. Eveline Celebrities liner is very praised and I wanted to try it, but by mistake I bought Liquid Precision 2000 procent liner in Black. On bottle it said, that's waterproof and that it has long lasting effect.


When I opened the liner, I was already dissapointed, I don't like these kinds of applicators. This applicator is soft, but it's impossible for me to do even line on my eyes with it. It always look like it would be wavy and then I thicken it and in the end I made it too thick. But it's at least great for wing in the end. The pigmentation of this liner is bad, I always have to do 2 coats, if I won't to have nice black liner on my eyes. On this photo you can see it in action and both of my problems, I already mention - not very straight line and bad pigmentation. It also should be waterproof, but it's not. If I have it for few hours on my lid and it's waterproof, I expect, it won't smudge, but this one does. The thing about long lasting effect it's true, it lasts all day on lids. I payed around 6 € for it, but to me it's not worth this money. Bottle contains 4 ml of product.


Next is Essence I Love Style liquid liner. As much as I know, Essence is discontinuig this one and they will release some new liners.


Essence has a bit rounded applicator in the end. I don't know, which function has that. The application of this liner is easy, because applicator is smooth, and it's very pigmented, much more than Eveline one. The only problem I have with this one is, that I can't apply thin line on my eyes with it. This liner is not waterproof. It's great for everyday use, because it stays long on eyes. The bottle contains 3,5 ml. I don't remember excatly, how much I payed for it, but now it's probably on sale in drugstores.


Swatches of both liners. As you can see here, Eveline is very easy to apply on hand. I wish it would be so easy to apply on my eyes too. Here also looks, like Essence is spilling on my hand, but on eyes that doesn't happen. Both are applied in 1 coat. When they dry, they both look matt.


Lately I'm using both together, because I want to finish them both, but I'm still searching my perfect black liner. I wouldn't buy again any of those two. Do you have any recommendation, which one is your favourite black liner? Thank you for reading.

19 komentarjev

  1. Sem tudi jaz gledala tegale Evelin v Nami, pa zdaj vidim da je dobro, da ga nisem vzela :)

    Jaz imam trenutno Waterproof Liquid Liner od Catrice, pa mi kar ustreza. Sicer ni na čopič, ampak je aplikator boljši kot pri teh dveh, rabiš samo en sloj pa ostane cel dan oz. ga imaš zvečer še problem dol dobit... Če ne drugega si ga poglej v Mullerju če ti ustreza :)

    OdgovoriIzbriši
    Odgovori
    1. Meni ni všeč, ne aplikator ne slaba pigmentiranost, sploh ne morem fajn delat z njim. :/
      Od Catrice še nisem probala nobenega, ker sem brala ene par recenzij pa so punce kritizirale. Hvala za priporočilo. :)

      Izbriši
  2. Moj najljubši tekoči eyeliner je od L'Oreala Super Liner Carbon Gloss. Je zelo pigmentiran, ultra črne barve, dolgo-obstojen, se ne razmaže in ima dovolj enostaven/natančen aplikator, da ga znam še jaz uporabljat. Ni pa najcenejši.
    Sem imela nekaj cenejših, tudi od Essence, in so proti temu nula.

    OdgovoriIzbriši
    Odgovori
    1. Hvala za priporočilo. Saj če je odličen izdelek, tudi malo višja cena ni problem. Za ta Eveline liner mi je bilo žal, da sem dala 6 €, ker ni vreden. :/

      Izbriši
  3. Jaz mam ogromno linerjev, ker jih največ nosim. Se strinjam, da je L'Oreal Super Liner Carbon Gloss super super, ampak sem predvsem zaradi cene vseeno probavala druge. Tega Essence sem kupila zdaj na razprodaji, pa nisem blazno navdušena ravno zaradi nezmožnosti tanke linije (in sicer sploh ne nosim tanke, ampak nisem imela občutka kontrole pri tem =/). Eveline, tisti drugi, je res res res upravičeno požel toliko pohval na blogih, po mojem mnenju najboljši liner ever! Sem mislila, da sem prevelik štor, da bi si lahko naredila tanko črto, z Eveline sploh ni problem, skoraj idiot proof! =))) Priporočam!

    OdgovoriIzbriši
    Odgovori
    1. Heh, sem oddala komentar, pa dala še eno možnost temu Essencu (kar čez obstoječo črto) =P Če narediš najprej pač debelejšo linijo čez oko po sredini, lahko s konico narediš prav lep tanek začetek in konec linije =) vesela! =D

      Izbriši
    2. Liner je tudi obvezen dodatek vsakemu mojemu makeupu. :) Saj z Essence linerjem se da delati, ko se malo naučiš rokovati z njim, ampak meni ni všeč aplikator in to, da dela predebelo črto. Raje imam aplikator, ki naredi tanko črto pa jo potem sama podebelim, koliko želim. Tisti Eveliner liner pa bom definitivno naslednjič probala, ampak bi rada ta 2 porabila prej.

      Izbriši
  4. Imam i ja taj Eveline eyeliner i super mi je!

    OdgovoriIzbriši
    Odgovori
    1. No, lepo, če vsaj tebi ustreza. :)

      Izbriši
  5. Super mi je što si ih usporedila. Ni na neću kupiti niti jednog od njih jer nisam dovoljno vična s eyelinerima..., a ovo se čine kao da iziskuju puno posla.

    Pozdrav!

    OdgovoriIzbriši
    Odgovori
    1. Se mi je zdelo, da bo imel post več smisla, če ju primerjam. Saj z linerji se da naučiti delati, jaz se še vedno učim potegniti lepo črto. Sicer pa je liner na očeh obvezen dodatek mojega makeupa. :)

      Izbriši
  6. "the application of this polish is easy, " hehe

    OdgovoriIzbriši
    Odgovori
    1. Haha. Hvala za opozorilo, sploh nisem opazila. :D

      Izbriši
  7. Imam ovaj od Essence-a i dan danas muku mučim s njim. Aplikator je good for nothing, pa ga je ocijedim na ruci i onda uzmem nail art brush i njime nanosim na oči. Inače je što se tiče pigmentacije genijalan, ali šteta što ga i najmanja kap vode briše.

    OdgovoriIzbriši
    Odgovori
    1. Aplikator je res slab, baje ga bo zdaj nadomestil nek drug s podobnim aplikatorjem, kot ga ima zgornji Evelinov. Bomo videli, če bo tisti boljši.

      Izbriši
  8. Ah Eveline makes Essence look awful. Zaista interesantno poređenje! :)

    OdgovoriIzbriši
    Odgovori
    1. Hvala. :) Čeprav meni je Essence liner dosti boljši od tega Evelinovega, moram probat še Celebrities liner.

      Izbriši
  9. a bas sam bila cula dobre kritike za ovaj eveline, za sad koristim gel liner, ali imam namjeru probat nesto ovakvo

    OdgovoriIzbriši
    Odgovori
    1. Poskusi Eveline Celebrities, tega vodoodpornega pa ti ne priporočam.

      Izbriši

Thank you for all your sweet comments, I appreciate every one of them. <3